Practice area · Extradition
Extradition lawyers: arrest warrant, surrender and non-refoulement
The firm's lawyers act for individuals targeted by an INTERPOL red notice or diffusion: applications to the CCF, deletion requests and extradition defence. Investigating chamber, European arrest warrant, non-refoulement and fair trial: a decisive part of the case is played out on the ground of surrender.
The phases of the procedure
The extradition procedure: from arrest to decision
The typical sequence comprises four phases: provisional arrest, judicial review of the detention, examination of the extradition request by the judicial authority, and, in most systems, the final decision of the executive. Each phase has its own time limits, grounds and actors, and the defence must be organised for each of them before the first even occurs: an arrest at the airport leaves no time to assemble a team.
Provisional arrest
Provisional arrest is the most brutal and the most closely regulated phase. A person who has been the subject of an alert may be arrested at the request of the requesting State before any formal extradition request, which is precisely the function that many States attach to the red notice or the diffusion, depending on the value their domestic law recognises in them. But this arrest is bound by strict time limits: under the European Convention on Extradition of 13 December 1957, Article 16 allows provisional arrest to be terminated if the formal extradition request and its supporting documents have not been received within eighteen days of the arrest, and in any event excludes such detention from exceeding forty days. Bilateral treaties contain analogous mechanisms, with varying time limits. The first battle of the defence is therefore twofold: to challenge the basis of the arrest (regularity of the alert, identity, characterisation) and to obtain release under judicial supervision pending the proceedings, by demonstrating guarantees of appearance.
Examination of the request
Examination of the request then engages the classic substantive conditions of extradition law. Dual criminality requires that the facts constitute an offence in both States; it is assessed on the facts, not on the labels, and the exotic economic characterisations of certain requesting States offer serious ground for challenge here. To these are added the political offence exception, the non-extradition of nationals in many systems, limitation periods, ne bis in idem, and humanitarian grounds (state of health, age, family situation) which most systems recognise in various forms, up to refusal where the surrender itself would expose the person to consequences of exceptional gravity.
Grounds for refusal
Refusal of extradition: real risk and human rights
Human rights-based grounds for refusal
Human rights-based grounds for refusal form the modern heart of the litigation. The Soering judgment (1989) forbids surrender where there is a real risk of treatment contrary to Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights; the Othman (Abu Qatada) judgment (2012) adds flagrant denial of justice and fixes the criteria for assessing diplomatic assurances (specificity, verification mechanism, the requesting State's prior practice with regard to its commitments).
The interim measure, the ultimate safeguard
When all domestic remedies are exhausted and surrender becomes imminent, the request for an interim measure under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court of the European Court of Human Rights constitutes the ultimate safeguard: since the Mamatkulov and Askarov v. Turkey judgment (Grand Chamber, 2005), non-compliance with an interim measure engages the responsibility of the respondent State. This request is prepared in advance: form, statement of the risk, decisive documents translated; improvisation in the last forty-eight hours before a surrender flight is the scenario that preparation must precisely exclude.
The extradition judge does not judge guilt: the judge assesses the conditions of surrender and the risks it entails. Arguing innocence is an error of forum; arguing dual criminality, speciality, grounds for refusal and risk within the meaning of the Soering, Othman and Sanchez-Sanchez judgments is the effective route.
Frequently asked questions
Extradition and arrest warrant: the essentials
Failure to meet the applicable treaty conditions, the political character of the offence, absence of dual criminality, limitation, breach of the rule of speciality, or a proven risk of violation of human rights and fair trial guarantees.
No. It does not constitute an arrest warrant and has no binding force in itself. It is a request to locate and, where appropriate, provisionally arrest a person, whose execution depends on the domestic law of each State. INTERPOL does not effect surrender: its role is location, notices, diffusions and police coordination.
Yes. A notice or a diffusion may be challenged before the Commission independently of any extradition proceedings already under way. However, the existence or risk of extradition shapes the strategy, the urgency and the documents to be produced.
Related practice areas
Continue within the firm's ecosystem
Details of applications to the CCF, INTERPOL defence as a whole and the practical guide.
A notice, a diffusion, an extradition? Let us talk.
Exposed individual, executive, company, political figure, family of a targeted individual or correspondent firm: from the moment you make contact, the firm examines the situation as a priority and can arrange an initial confidential orientation discussion, in order to assess the critical deadlines and identify the relevant options. The initial discussion entails no mutual commitment. In French, English and Spanish.

