Practice area · European Court of Human Rights
ECHR lawyers: application to the European Court and Rule 39 interim measure
The firm's lawyers act in human rights cases before the European Court of Human Rights and United Nations bodies: arbitrary detention, fair trial, interim measures. Individual application against a member State of the Council of Europe, after exhaustion of domestic remedies, and interim measure under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court where removal or an imminent risk so warrants.
The individual application
The application to the European Court: admissibility and time limit
Admissibility is not a preliminary formality: before the European Court it is where the great majority of applications are lost, and before all bodies a largely avoidable cause of failure. The practitioner must therefore treat the admissibility analysis as a phase in its own right, documented by a written note, before any decision to seise a forum.
Exhaustion of domestic remedies
Required by Article 35 of the European Convention as well as by the United Nations and regional instruments, it follows a precise logic structured by the judgment in Akdivar and Others v. Turkey (1996): the applicant must have used the available and effective domestic remedies, raising in substance before the national court the complaints they intend to bring at the international level; but the obligation concerns only remedies offering reasonable prospects of success, and the burden of proof is shared: it is for the State pleading non-exhaustion to show the existence of an effective and available remedy, and then for the applicant to show that the remedy was used or that it was inadequate, ineffective, or that special circumstances absolved them from using it. The most frequent pitfall is not the absence of a domestic remedy but the badly calibrated domestic remedy: an appeal that did not raise the Convention complaint in substance, a remedy used that was not the effective one, a remedy abandoned along the way.
The time limit for applying
The time limit is the harshest condition. Before the European Court, the application must be lodged within four months of the final domestic decision, a time limit reduced from six to four months by Article 4 of Protocol No. 15, applicable since 1 February 2022 (the Protocol itself having entered into force on 1 August 2021), which older sources, still widely cited, do not reflect; an application lodged out of time is rejected as inadmissible (Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention). Time starts to run on the day after the day on which the final decision was pronounced in public or on which the applicant or their representative was informed of it, knowledge by the lawyer being sufficient even if the client learns of it later; it expires four calendar months later, without extension where the last day falls on a Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday. In case of doubt, the only safe practice is to adopt the least favourable method of computation.
A considerable part of the documentation available online still mentions the former six-month time limit. Relying on an outdated source on this precise point is enough to lose access to the Court permanently.
Interim measures
The interim measure under Rule 39
Interim measures are the emergency tool of international litigation: they aim to preserve the situation pending examination on the merits, where the applicant is exposed to an imminent risk of serious and irreparable harm.
Conditions of the request
The request must establish three elements: the imminence of the risk (a removal date, an enforceable decision, a documented state of health); the seriousness of the feared harm and the difficulty of repairing it; and the link with the arguable complaints on the merits. General, speculative or undocumented requests are dismissed: the European Court regularly recalls that the Rule 39 mechanism is reserved for exceptional and strictly documented situations. The emergency file must therefore be prepared as a miniature merits file: enforceable domestic decision, evidence of the risk in the State of destination, medical certificates, chronology, all of it immediately available.
Key point
Since Mamatkulov and Askarov (2005), non-compliance with an interim measure of the European Court entails a violation of Article 34 of the Convention, unless the State shows that an objective impediment prevented it from complying (Paladi v. Moldova [GC], 2009). An interim measure is not a mere wish: it is an obligation, the disregard of which creates an autonomous complaint, and a lever in all parallel proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
Application and interim measure: the essentials
From strategy to forum, from emergencies to situations: the answers follow the order of the decisions to be taken, that of a real case.
A measure indicated by the European Court of Human Rights under Rule 39 of its Rules of Court, which suspends a measure, most often a removal, pending examination. It is granted where an imminent and irreparable risk is established, and the State is bound to comply with it: failure to comply hinders the right of individual application guaranteed by Article 34 of the Convention. The UN mechanisms and the Inter-American Commission and Court of Human Rights have equivalent arrangements.
As a general rule, yes: an application to an international forum requires the prior exhaustion of effective domestic remedies. Exceptions exist, in particular where those remedies are unavailable, ineffective or unreasonably prolonged. Certain mechanisms are exempt by design: the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention and the special procedures may be seised without prior exhaustion, and the ECOWAS Court of Justice offers direct individual access free of that requirement. Urgency may also justify a parallel protective application.
Further reading
Continue within the firm's ecosystem
A detention, a rigged trial, a dangerous extradition? Let us talk.
Detained person and their family, opposition figure, candidate, journalist, human rights defender, exposed executive, religious community, organisation or correspondent firm: from the moment you make contact, the firm examines the situation as a priority and can arrange an initial confidential orientation discussion, in order to assess the urgency, characterise the situation and identify the relevant options. The initial discussion entails no mutual commitment. In French, English and Spanish.

