Practice area · Arbitrary detention
Arbitrary detention lawyers: United Nations and international remedies
Strategic litigation consists in moving the case to the forum where the law can still take effect. The firm's lawyers act in human rights cases before the European Court of Human Rights and United Nations bodies: arbitrary detention, fair trial, interim measures.
UN mechanisms
The United Nations Working Group and urgent appeals
An opinion of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, a communication from special rapporteurs, the Views of a treaty body become key documents before the extradition judge, the protection officer, the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files and the sanctions authorities.
The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention
The Working Group on Arbitrary Detention occupies a singular place where the person targeted, a relative or an associate is detained, in the originating State or in a third State acting at its request. Its methodology classifies deprivations of liberty into five categories: absence of any legal basis (Category I); detention resulting from the exercise of guaranteed rights or freedoms, notably freedom of expression and participation in public life (Category II); violations of fair trial guarantees so grave as to give the deprivation of liberty an arbitrary character (Category III); prolonged administrative detention of asylum seekers, migrants or refugees without the possibility of administrative or judicial review or remedy (Category IV); discriminatory detention (Category V). Categories II and III are the natural framework of repression cases: they make it possible to have a detention that is formally based on a criminal case characterised as arbitrary, by targeting the exercise of freedoms and the collapse of procedural guarantees.
United Nations special procedures
Special rapporteurs and working groups on torture, the independence of judges and lawyers, freedom of expression, freedom of religion and the situation of human rights defenders: urgent appeals and communications, available in an emergency and over the long term alike. The special procedures of the Human Rights Council are the fastest tool. Special rapporteurs and thematic working groups may be seised without any requirement of exhaustion of domestic remedies and may send States communications, including urgent ones, on individual cases. A communication is not binding, but it has three practical effects: it places the case in the official documentation of the United Nations, it imposes on the originating State the diplomatic cost of a reply, and it dates international knowledge of the situation, which matters when, later, a body must assess the credibility of a risk alleged long ago.
Frequently asked questions
Arbitrary detention at the international level: the essentials
From strategy to forum, from emergencies to situations: the answers follow the order of the decisions to be taken, that of a real case.
Yes. An arrest, a scheduled extradition, a risk of torture or an urgent appeal to be launched fall within the Crisis Room: the first contact is examined as a priority. The initial orientation discussion is confidential and without mutual commitment; its purpose is to assess the urgency, characterise the situation and identify the relevant options. The firm operates natively in French, English and Spanish, can adapt the arrangements for the initial review to the humanitarian or institutional nature of the situation, and draws on an international network of correspondents selected case by case.
That depends on the ratifications, declarations and reservations of the State concerned. Direct individual recourse to the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights requires a declaration under Article 34(6), which some States have never deposited or have withdrawn; communications before the Human Rights Committee require acceptance of the Optional Protocol. Nationality, by contrast, is irrelevant: the guarantees benefit every person within the jurisdiction of the State, whatever their nationality. This State-by-State mapping is the prerequisite to any choice of forum.
Further reading
Continue within the firm's ecosystem
A detention, a rigged trial, a dangerous extradition? Let us talk.
Detained person and their family, opposition figure, candidate, journalist, human rights defender, exposed executive, religious community, organisation or correspondent firm: from the moment you make contact, the firm examines the situation as a priority and can arrange an initial confidential orientation discussion, in order to assess the urgency, characterise the situation and identify the relevant options. The initial discussion entails no mutual commitment. In French, English and Spanish.

